Jeremy Godfrey is a citizen of Night Vale. He was a witness to the invasion of Night Vale from the mysterious underground city from beneath lane five of the Desert Flower Bowling Alley and Arcade Fun Complex, as he had rented out a couple of lanes for his fiftieth birthday party.

These events left him rather disappointed, staring out at the sky for the rest of the day, until the Apache tracker saved from the invaders. Upon the apache tracker's death, he slumped once again into his chair, saying, “This is the worst birthday party anyone has ever had.”